FOR PROFESSIONAL ATHLETES

His CPA Tax Services Missed 9 States. It Cost Him $187,000 in One Season.

He earned it in twelve states. His CPA filed in one.

Eighteen months after he signed a $2.4 million contract, I watched him open notices from nine different state tax agencies. The number at the bottom read $187,000. His CPA was not careless. He was a good accountant for a W-2 household, and this is what happened when that met an athlete's income.

Book Free Review

Real accountants Flat monthly pricing Every state filed for you

Phoenix · August 25, 2026 · 6 min read

One athlete. Real numbers.

$187,000

assessed by nine states in one season

“I made the money in twelve different states. My CPA filed in one. Now every game is logged before I get on the plane, and I finally know what I actually kept this year.”

A pro athlete, shared with permission · Multi-state professional, $2.4M contract

The Story

A $2.4 million contract, one state return, nine angry states

He hired the CPA his family had used for two decades and assumed the hard part was over. The CPA filed one clean federal return and one resident state return, the same way he had for the player's parents since middle school. Nobody filed the nonresident returns for the nine states where he played road games and earned income. Eighteen months later the assessments arrived, with interest compounding since the original due dates.

The bill, as nine states added it up

Tax actually owed across nine states$94,000

Penalties and accrued interest$93,000

Nonresident returns his CPA filed1 of 10

Notices in the mailbox, 18 months later$187,000

The Problem

Every road game is a tax event. Most CPAs never learn that.

Play a game in California and California wants a slice of that day's income, even if you live in Florida and never file there. Multiply that by an 82-game season, or 17 weekends of away games, and you have a filing puzzle a generalist never needs to solve for anyone else on their client list. Add a signing bonus taxed under different rules than salary and agent fees nobody reconciles, and the system is opaque by design. If you are skeptical that a new accountant can fix this, you should be: most of them are the same once-a-year filing with a nicer logo.

What We Tried

A bigger firm, a bundled advisor, and his brother's spreadsheet

He tried the obvious fixes before anyone found the real problem. His agent recommended a bigger firm. The agency bundled in a financial advisor. His older brother built a spreadsheet to keep an eye on things. None of them addressed the one thing his job legally required: nonresident state returns in every state where he earned a game check.

What each one actually did

	Family CPA	Agency bundle
Files a clean federal return
Nonresident returns in every game state	1 of 10
Signing bonus taxed under its own rules
Agent and trainer fees tracked in season		Guessed in April
Estimate schedule matched to the game calendar
Planning built for a 3 to 10 year career window

Sound familiar? A 30-minute call tells you exactly where you stand.

Book Free Review

Free 30-minute review. No pitch deck.

The Discovery

Almost half the bill was the cost of not knowing

The turning point was a second opinion that looked at two years of returns and found the gap in about forty minutes. Nine states where he had played, earned, and owed tax had zero filings on record. Not underpaid. Unfiled. The underlying tax was closer to $94,000; penalties and accrued interest made up the other $93,000, and that entire second half would have been erased by filing correctly and on time.

Same income, two ways to file

Filed once a year, nine states missed$187K

Filed on time in every state$94K

His numbers, nine nonresident states, two seasons

The FixAMADAE

Every game logged against every state, before the deadline

Amadae was built for exactly this income shape: large, fast, multi-jurisdictional, and time-limited. Every road game gets logged against that state's withholding and filing threshold as the season happens, and the nonresident returns get filed before they become a problem instead of after. Signing bonus income is separated from salary and taxed under the correct rules. Agent, trainer, and advisor fees are categorized in real time, and books, payroll, and every return are covered by one flat monthly price.

Book Free Review

Set up before his next season

Nine nonresident returns filed and cleared
Every game logged against its state threshold
Signing bonus separated from salary
Agent, trainer, and advisor fees tracked live
Quarterly estimates matched to the game calendar

The Proof

Two seasons later: zero notices, and a real answer

The same player now has no outstanding state notices and a quarterly estimate schedule that matches his actual game calendar. For the first time he has a real answer when someone asks what he actually keeps. This July, instead of bracing for a surprise, he had already funded his retirement account for the year and knew exactly what training camp income would cost him in September.

“I made the money in twelve different states. My CPA filed in one. Now every game is logged before I get on the plane, and I finally know what I actually kept this year.”

A pro athlete, shared with permission

Multi-state professional, $2.4M contract

Zero outstanding state notices two seasons later

Why NowAMADAE

The off-season is the window. Camp closes it.

Every summer that passes without a real system is a summer where quarterly estimates, state exposure, and entity decisions pile up quietly, right up until fall camp starts and there is no time left to fix it. Before the schedule takes over your calendar, Amadae will review your current filings, your multi-state exposure, and your entity structure on a free intro call. No cost, no contract, and if you are already covered we will say so.

Book Free Review

$93,000

of his bill was penalties and interest. The cost of not knowing, not the cost of earning.

His state notices, nine jurisdictions

One athlete. Real numbers.

$187,000

assessed by nine states in one season

$93,000

of it was penalties and interest

states with zero filings on record

40 min

for a second opinion to find the gap

One client, with permission. Your numbers will differ.

Accounting built for a multi-state career

Books, payroll, and every state return from real accountants, for one flat monthly price starting at $249.

Every road game logged against its state filing threshold
Signing bonus and salary taxed under the correct rules
Quarterly estimates matched to your actual game calendar
Federal, resident, and nonresident returns filed for you

Book Free Review

No long-term contract. Cancel any time. The intro call is free.

Plans from

$249/mo

If you make $40K - $69K. Flat, no hourly bills.

Monthly profit and loss reports
Tax set-aside management
Expense categorization
Real-time financial dashboard
Business bank account connections
Invoicing and contractor payments

Book Free Review

Cancel any timeReal accountantsTaxes filed for you

Straight answers

Questions creators ask us

My agent already has someone for this.+

Usually that someone is a generalist bundled into a management package, filing one clean federal return and calling it done. Ask them how many nonresident state returns they filed for you last season. If the answer is one, that is the gap.

I do not want to switch mid-season and mess things up.+

You do not have to touch anything already filed. Specialized multi-state tracking layers on top of an existing setup, and the review starts with what is on record, not with tearing it up.

Can I deal with this before next season instead?+

That is what most players say in July. The problem is that penalties and interest have been compounding since the original due dates, and once camp opens there is no time. The review takes one call.

What does it cost?+

Plans start at $249 a month, flat, with books, payroll, and returns included. No hourly bills, and no surprise invoices when nine states send notices.

Check the math before the games start again

One call with an athlete-focused accountant. A real picture of what you are keeping and which states are still waiting on you. Free.

Book Free Review

Keep reading

We Reviewed One NFL Free Agent's Service Taxes. His Signing Bonus Cost Him $141,000.

Most athletes assume someone else is handling their service taxes. We reviewed one free agent's state filings and found a $141,000 mistake hiding inside his signing bonus.

We Reviewed 11 State Tax Filings For One NFL Rookie. His Tax Prep Missed 3.

Most business tax preparation services file your return once a year and call it done. Here's what happened when one NFL rookie's flat-fee tax prep missed 3 states out of 11.

I Found a $61,000 Tax Mistake in a Rookie's Contract. A CPA for S Corp Fixed It in One Meeting.

A rookie point guard almost lost $61,000 to a tax structure nobody explained. Here's what a CPA for S corp move actually changes for pro athletes. 8 min read.