AMADAEBook Free Review

FOR PRO ATHLETES

We Reviewed One NFL Free Agent's Service Taxes. His Signing Bonus Cost Him $141,000.

His CPA filed on time every year. He still overpaid nine states.

Last July, right after he signed as a free agent, we sat down with an NFL veteran who had spent eight seasons on the road. Every return of his career had been filed on time. He still owed nine states money he never should have paid, and the biggest single error was sitting inside the payment that was supposed to be the safest money he had ever made.

Book Free Review
Real accountants Flat monthly pricing Taxes filed for you

Phoenix · Updated September 24, 2026 · 6 min read

Sprinter driving off the blocks on a red track

One free agent. Nine states. One misread bonus.

$141,000

overpaid on the signing bonus alone

“I thought paying someone meant it was handled. It meant I was current, not correct. That's a $141,000 difference.”

Amadae client · NFL free agent, eight seasons

The Story

A $2M signing bonus, sliced across nine states

More than $2 million of his signing bonus had been apportioned across every state he played in that year, instead of being taxed once, in his home state, exactly the way the law allows. This is not a loophole and it is not aggressive. It is the correct treatment, and it got missed because the person filing his return was managing a form, not managing him.

The signing bonus, as his preparer filed it

Signing bonus apportioned across game states$2,000,000+
States that taxed a slice of it9
States that should have: his home state1
Amended returns needed9
Overpaid on the signing bonus alone$141,000

The Problem

Service taxes follow the work, not the paycheck

Service taxes are state income tax on income earned for services performed inside that state's border, and for an athlete the service is the game. Play in California, Illinois, and New York in one month and three states have a claim on that income. A pro athlete can file in more states in one year than most Americans file in a lifetime, each with its own duty-day formula and deadline. Here is what we hear on nearly every intake call: I assumed my CPA had this handled. I do not play in enough states for this to matter. All of it was wrong for him.

14 to 20

separate state returns a pro athlete can file in a single year, each with its own sourcing rule, duty-day formula, and deadline

Amadae athlete files, two years

What We Tried

Current is not the same as correct

A business manager's office is built to keep you current, not to catch a misclassified payment or an over-apportioned bill. Those are two different jobs. His prior preparer apportioned the signing bonus the same way they apportioned his game checks, because it was faster and nobody had flagged the distinction. Compliance shops get graded on whether a return is filed by the deadline, not on whether it is filed in the player's favor.

Who does what

Business managerGeneralist CPAAmadae
Files on time in every stateUsually
Duty days rebuilt from travel logs, not memory
Signing bonus classified apart from game checks
Filed in the player's favor, not just by the deadline
Plans the whole career window

Sound familiar? A 30-minute call tells you exactly where you stand.

Talk to Us

Free 30-minute review. No pitch deck.

The Discovery

A signing bonus is not income for playing games

Most state tax codes source income for services to where the services are performed. But a one-time payment for signing a contract, not conditioned on future performance, not tied to games played, and payable whether or not he ever takes a snap, is compensation for signing, not for performing services in any particular state. That means it is generally taxable only in your state of domicile. If a bonus is instead paid out over the life of the contract, or forfeited for missing games or violating conduct clauses, that conditional language is exactly what pulls it back into service-income territory and apportionment across every state played; his contract had none of those strings, so it stayed put in his home state. His contract met every one of those conditions.

States taxing his signing bonus

As filed: apportioned across the schedule9 states
As the law allows: home state only1 state

A bonus not conditioned on future services is taxed in the state of domicile; the difference on his was $141,000

The FixAMADAE

Rebuilt from travel logs, filed in nine states, recovered

We rebuilt his duty-day calendar from travel logs and team records, not memory. We reclassified the signing bonus correctly under his resident state's rules, filed the amended returns across every state that had taxed it, and recovered the overpayment. Then we built the part that protects him going forward: a system that tracks every game and practice day, every away-state filing requirement, and every dollar of signing bonus, salary, and endorsement income separately, mapped against apportionment rules before the season starts, not after the bill arrives.

Get Started
Consultant presenting at a whiteboard to a full table
Duty-day calendar from travel logs, the signing bonus classified once in the home state, every away-state filing coordinated before the season starts.

The Proof

$141,000 back, and where it went

The recovered money went into his solo 401(k) built on endorsement income and a reserve fund for the years after the last contract, the two things every player says they will build later and almost never do while the checks are still coming. His case was not isolated, another client's prior preparer missed filings across almost every state he played in that year, and the cost is in the stats above.

“I thought paying someone meant it was handled. It meant I was current, not correct. That's a $141,000 difference.”

A

Amadae client

NFL free agent, eight seasons

$141,000 recovered into retirement and reserve

Why NowAMADAE

Contracts are signing now. Your exposure just reset.

Every new contract starts a new duty-day calendar and a new set of away-state obligations, whether anyone is tracking them or not. Athletes do not get decades to plan slowly; the strategy you skip this season does not come back around next contract. The ones who get ahead of it now file correctly all year. The ones who wait find out in February. We will review your current state filings, your bonus classifications, and your duty-day exposure at no cost and tell you what we find, whether that number is $0 or six figures.

Get Started

9 of 10

athlete files we reviewed over two years had at least one state tax error large enough to require an amended return

Amadae athlete file reviews, two years

One free agent. Nine states. One misread bonus.

$141,000

overpaid on the signing bonus alone

9

states that taxed a bonus only one should have

9 of 10

athlete files with an error needing an amended return

$187,000

another client lost in one year to nine unfiled states

Amadae athlete client files, two years, with permission. Your numbers will differ.

Accounting built for a career played across state lines

Books, payroll, and taxes from real accountants, for one flat monthly price starting at $249.

  • Duty-day tracking built from your actual game and travel calendar, updated as the schedule moves
  • Bonus classification review so signing money is taxed once, correctly
  • Coordinated multi-state filing and quarterly estimates for every game state
  • Career-window tax strategy, not just this year's return
Get My Review

No long-term contract. Cancel any time. The review is free.

Plans from

$249/mo

If you make $40K - $69K. Flat, no hourly bills.

  • Monthly profit and loss reports
  • Tax set-aside management
  • Expense categorization
  • Real-time financial dashboard
  • Business bank account connections
  • Individual tax return included*
Start Today
Flat monthly pricingReal accountantsTaxes filed for you

Straight answers

Questions creators ask us

My business manager already handles my taxes.+

The free agent said this too. A back office keeps you current; it is not built to catch a misclassified bonus or an over-apportioned state bill. One keeps the trains running. The other makes sure you are not overpaying to ride them.

I only played six away games. This can't be worth much.+

Six away games in six states is six separate exposures, six duty-day calculations, and six chances for a preparer to get the apportionment wrong. The dollar amount scales with your contract, not with the number of trips.

Will amending nine state returns trigger audits?+

Amended returns that apply the correct bonus treatment and a documented duty-day count are the opposite of aggressive. We file them with the travel logs and contract language attached, so each state sees exactly why the number changed.

Sources

  1. IRS Self-Employed Individuals Tax Center · IRS
  2. IRS: Estimated Taxes · IRS
  3. IRS Schedule C (Form 1040), Profit or Loss From Business · IRS
  4. IRS: Deducting Business Expenses · IRS

Ready for peace of mind?

Amadae will give you time back for what matters most.

Book Free Review
Service Taxes: How One NFL Free Agent Overpaid $141,000 - Amadae